* 1921 - Margaret Gorman
* 1933 - Marian Bergeron
* 1945 - Bess Myerson
* 1958 - Marilyn Van Derbur
* 1970 - Pamela Eldred
* 1984 - Vanessa Williams
* 1993 - Leanza Cornett
* 2001 - Angela Pérez Baraquio
* 2011 - Teresa Scanlan
* 2021 - Emma Broyles